Federal Tax Liens - Revision history

Alanfields: /* I. IRS Distraint Sales */

2025-05-15T16:02:21Z

‎I. IRS Distraint Sales

Alanfields: /* Foreclosure of Federal Tax Liens */

2025-05-15T16:01:47Z

‎Foreclosure of Federal Tax Liens

Alanfields: /* Foreclosure of Federal Tax Liens */

2025-05-15T15:57:21Z

‎Foreclosure of Federal Tax Liens

Alanfields: /* Foreclosure of Federal Tax Liens */

2025-05-15T15:54:33Z

‎Foreclosure of Federal Tax Liens

Alanfields at 15:50, 15 May 2025

2025-05-15T15:50:58Z

Alanfields: /* Other Terminable Interests */

2022-11-18T15:58:20Z

‎Other Terminable Interests

Alanfields: /* Tenancy by Entireties */

2021-11-30T20:39:27Z

‎Tenancy by Entireties

Alanfields: /* Purchase Money Mortgage and Federal Tax Liens */

2018-10-24T00:10:04Z

‎Purchase Money Mortgage and Federal Tax Liens

Alanfields: /* Purchase Money Mortgage and Federal Tax Liens */

2018-10-24T00:08:14Z

‎Purchase Money Mortgage and Federal Tax Liens

Alanfields: /* Can a Tax Lien be Foreclosed Out? What rights of Redemption? */

2017-10-16T22:21:41Z

‎Can a Tax Lien be Foreclosed Out? What rights of Redemption?

@@ Line 147: / Line 147: @@
 They’ll need to obtain the record of the sale from the IRS.  (Record 21 in IRS speak.)  The IRS will complain about it, but their regulations say they have to make the full record available to the purchaser and/or a title insurer.  Here’s the guidelines for a distraint sale from a CLE I did in Ohio 15 plus years ago, but nothing has changed:
-===I.	IRS Distraint Sales===
+===IRS Distraint Sales===
 ====Background:====

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:01, 15 May 2025
Line 140:		Line 140:
	Was it a Distraint Sale or a judicial foreclosure in Federal District Court?		Was it a Distraint Sale or a judicial foreclosure in Federal District Court?

		+	===IRS Judicial Foreclosure===
	If it’s a judicial, it’s just like any other judicial foreclosure: name all parties with an interest in the real estate as defendants, serve them according to the Federal Civil Rules, etc. The Service does a really good job on judicial foreclosures of FTLs.		If it’s a judicial, it’s just like any other judicial foreclosure: name all parties with an interest in the real estate as defendants, serve them according to the Federal Civil Rules, etc. The Service does a really good job on judicial foreclosures of FTLs.

@@ Line 146: / Line 146: @@
 They’ll need to obtain the record of the sale from the IRS.  (Record 21 in IRS speak.)  The IRS will complain about it, but their regulations say they have to make the full record available to the purchaser and/or a title insurer.  Here’s the guidelines for a distraint sale from a CLE I did in Ohio 15 plus years ago, but nothing has changed:
-I.	IRS Distraint Sales
+===I.	IRS Distraint Sales===
-Background:          The Internal Revenue has two ways to sell real estate in order to satisfy the tax obligations owed by the real estate’s owner.  The IRS may foreclose a Federal Tax Lien by filing a foreclosure suit in Federal District Court or may sell the property subject to a Federal Tax Lien in a non-judicial procedure known as a distraint sale.
+====Background:====
-Risk:                     Distraint Sales are authorized by 26 USC 6331; however, such a sale sells only the taxpayer’s interest in the real estate.  A buyer at a distraint sale takes title subject to liens perfected prior to the Federal Tax Lien (Senior liens), dower claims of the taxpayer’s spouse, if any, the interests of co-owners, real estate taxes, restrictions, easements and in many cases, liens which attached subsequent to the Federal Tax Lien (Junior liens).
+====Risk:====
-Standard:              As a general rule, the IRS rarely follows its own manual detailing the procedures for conducting a distraint sale and the examination required to underwrite such a sale is rarely worth the time and expense since most distraint sales cannot be insured.
+====Standard:====
-                        The key to insuring a distraint sale is ensuring that there are no senior liens, no outstanding dower issues, no co-owners and identifying junior lienholders.   After this determination, you must make an examination of the IRS’ records of the distraint sale.  This record is known as the “Record of Seizure and Sale of Real Estate”, but is commonly called the Record  21.
+The key to insuring a distraint sale is ensuring that there are no senior liens, no outstanding dower issues, no co-owners and identifying junior lienholders.   After this determination, you must make an examination of the IRS’ records of the distraint sale.  This record is known as the “Record of Seizure and Sale of Real Estate”, but is commonly called the Record  21.
-                        The Record 21 consists of two part.  Part One is for the use of the IRS and Part Two is for the use of the public.  However, IRS Regulations state that the full Record 21 will be made available to the purchaser or a title insurer.  A full copy of the Record 21 must be obtained for your file.
+The Record 21 consists of two part.  Part One is for the use of the IRS and Part Two is for the use of the public.  However, IRS Regulations state that the full Record 21 will be made available to the purchaser or a title insurer.  A full copy of the Record 21 must be obtained for your file.
 To insure title to real estate that was sold at a distraint sale, you must ask the following:
@@ Line 178: / Line 181: @@
 In practice, the IRS rarely gives constitutionally adequate notice to junior lienholders!  Why?  Under 26 USC 6339(c), the issuance of a deed to the purchaser of a distraint sale discharges liens that are junior to the Federal Tax Lien.  As a consequence, the IRS often takes the position that the publication/posting of the sale notice is sufficient to notify junior lienholders and eliminate their interests.
-However, see Mennonite Board of Missions v. Adams, 462 US 103.  The US Supreme Court held that notice by publication of a tax foreclosure as to a mortgage holder failed to meet the requirements of due process guaranteed by the 5th Amendment to the US Constitution when the address of the mortgagee could be ascertained by “reasonably diligent efforts”.
+However, see [https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/462/791/ Mennonite Board of Missions v. Adams, 462 US 103 (1983)].  The US Supreme Court held that notice by publication of a tax foreclosure as to a mortgage holder failed to meet the requirements of due process guaranteed by the 5th Amendment to the US Constitution when the address of the mortgagee could be ascertained by “reasonably diligent efforts”.
 Finally, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has held that publication/posting of the notice of sale is constitutionally inadequate to protect the interests of junior lien holders in a distraint sale.  See Verba vs. Ohio Casualty Insurance Co., 851 F.2d 811 (1988).  Also, see Internal Revenue Manual 5.17.3.6.1.2(3).  This portion of the Internal Revenue Manual requires the notice of sale to be served on all parties with an interest in the real estate via regular mail and provides IRS personnel with a citation to Verba vs. Ohio Casualty.

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:54, 15 May 2025
Line 135:		Line 135:

	==Foreclosure of Federal Tax Liens==		==Foreclosure of Federal Tax Liens==
		+
		+	Sam Shellhaas 5-15-2025
		+
		+	Was it a Distraint Sale or a judicial foreclosure in Federal District Court?
		+
		+	If it’s a judicial, it’s just like any other judicial foreclosure: name all parties with an interest in the real estate as defendants, serve them according to the Federal Civil Rules, etc. The Service does a really good job on judicial foreclosures of FTLs.
		+
		+	If it’s a Distraint Sale, I’d tell the agent that it’s probably not worth looking at. I’ve probably looked at 20-30 of them and I’ve seen one that could be insured. It’s a shame as the IRS has an excellent manual for their agents who are conducting distraint sales, but they just don’t follow it.
		+
		+	They’ll need to obtain the record of the sale from the IRS. (Record 21 in IRS speak.) The IRS will complain about it, but their regulations say they have to make the full record available to the purchaser and/or a title insurer. Here’s the guidelines for a distraint sale from a CLE I did in Ohio 15 plus years ago, but nothing has changed:
		+
		+	I. IRS Distraint Sales
		+
		+	Background: The Internal Revenue has two ways to sell real estate in order to satisfy the tax obligations owed by the real estate’s owner. The IRS may foreclose a Federal Tax Lien by filing a foreclosure suit in Federal District Court or may sell the property subject to a Federal Tax Lien in a non-judicial procedure known as a distraint sale.
		+
		+	Risk: Distraint Sales are authorized by 26 USC 6331; however, such a sale sells only the taxpayer’s interest in the real estate. A buyer at a distraint sale takes title subject to liens perfected prior to the Federal Tax Lien (Senior liens), dower claims of the taxpayer’s spouse, if any, the interests of co-owners, real estate taxes, restrictions, easements and in many cases, liens which attached subsequent to the Federal Tax Lien (Junior liens).
		+
		+	Standard: As a general rule, the IRS rarely follows its own manual detailing the procedures for conducting a distraint sale and the examination required to underwrite such a sale is rarely worth the time and expense since most distraint sales cannot be insured.
		+
		+	The key to insuring a distraint sale is ensuring that there are no senior liens, no outstanding dower issues, no co-owners and identifying junior lienholders. After this determination, you must make an examination of the IRS’ records of the distraint sale. This record is known as the “Record of Seizure and Sale of Real Estate”, but is commonly called the Record 21.
		+
		+	The Record 21 consists of two part. Part One is for the use of the IRS and Part Two is for the use of the public. However, IRS Regulations state that the full Record 21 will be made available to the purchaser or a title insurer. A full copy of the Record 21 must be obtained for your file.
		+
		+	To insure title to real estate that was sold at a distraint sale, you must ask the following:
		+
		+	1. Was a Notice of Federal Tax Lien filed against the taxpayer whose real estate was sold by the IRS? No Federal Tax Lien, no distraint sale.
		+
		+	2. Did the IRS give the affected taxpayer a notice and demand for payment of the delinquent tax? If so, did the IRS levy (sell) on the real estate within 10 days after this notice? Prior to proceeding to a distraint sale, the IRS must give the affected taxpayer a notice and demand for payment. The IRS cannot sell the property within 10 days of this notice unless the IRS made a finding that collection of the tax was in jeopardy and the notice and demand was for immediate payment of the tax. See [https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/6331 26 USC 6331](a).
		+
		+	3. Did the IRS give the taxpayer/owner a notice of “seizure”, in writing, specifying the amount due and demanded as well as a description of the real estate seized? If so, was the “seizure” conducted within 6 months of the date of assessment of the tax?
		+
		+	The seizure notice must be either personally delivered to the taxpayer/owner or left at their usual place of abode or business provided it is located within the IRS District where the seizure was made. When the residence/business is located outside the IRS District, the IRS may send the seizure notice to the last known address by regular and certified mail. No seizure notice, no sale. Remember that the seizure date must be within 6 months of the date of assessment. (See Column d on the Notice of Federal Tax Lien for the assessment date) See [https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/6502 26 USC 6502].
		+
		+	4. Did the IRS give the taxpayer/owner notice of the sale including the time, place, manner and conditions of the sale? If the taxpayer/owner resides or has their business in the same IRS District where the seizure was made, IRS regulations (Internal Revenue Manual 5.10.4.11(1)) requires personal delivery of the Notice of Sale. If the taxpayer/owner cannot be readily located or does not reside or have a place of business in the IRS District where the seizure was made, the notice of sale will be sent via certified and regular mail.
		+
		+	However, if the address is known, can be located and is within the IRS District were the property was served, the Internal Revenue Manual requires that personal contact with the taxpayer must be attempted, and that the notice be left on the door of the residence/business (“door knob” service) when personal delivery cannot be made. Service via certified/regular mail may be attempted in this situation, but are insufficient without “door knob” service. See Internal Revenue Manual 5.10.4.11(2).
		+
		+	5. Did the IRS publish the notice of sale in a newspaper published or generally circulated within the county where the real property was made? If no such newspaper exists, was the notice of sale posted at the nearest post office and two other public places located within that county? The property to be sold is not considered a public place, but a public library or courthouse is. If not, no sale.
		+
		+	6. Did the IRS notify other lienholders and persons with an interest in the real estate of the notice of sale? Even though the distraint sale does not sell the property free and clear of senior liens, dower, and co-owners, the IRS is required to give notice of the sale via regular mail to all parties with a record interest in the real estate: joint-owners, senior lienholders, junior lienholders, transferees, nominees and judgment creditors regardless of whether they have perfected a lien. See Internal Revenue Manual 5.17.3.6.1.2(3) and 5.10.4.11(5).
		+
		+	In practice, the IRS rarely gives constitutionally adequate notice to junior lienholders! Why? Under 26 USC 6339(c), the issuance of a deed to the purchaser of a distraint sale discharges liens that are junior to the Federal Tax Lien. As a consequence, the IRS often takes the position that the publication/posting of the sale notice is sufficient to notify junior lienholders and eliminate their interests.
		+
		+	However, see Mennonite Board of Missions v. Adams, 462 US 103. The US Supreme Court held that notice by publication of a tax foreclosure as to a mortgage holder failed to meet the requirements of due process guaranteed by the 5th Amendment to the US Constitution when the address of the mortgagee could be ascertained by “reasonably diligent efforts”.
		+
		+	Finally, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has held that publication/posting of the notice of sale is constitutionally inadequate to protect the interests of junior lien holders in a distraint sale. See Verba vs. Ohio Casualty Insurance Co., 851 F.2d 811 (1988). Also, see Internal Revenue Manual 5.17.3.6.1.2(3). This portion of the Internal Revenue Manual requires the notice of sale to be served on all parties with an interest in the real estate via regular mail and provides IRS personnel with a citation to Verba vs. Ohio Casualty.
		+
		+	The Record 21 will contain a section specifying who was given notice of the sale and how notice was provided. If it does not, then further inquiry is necessary. Often, the IRS will attach a Form 2434B to the Record 21 listing the encumbrances against the property. The Form 2434B should not be relied upon and an examination of the public records should be made in order to ensure that all parties with an interest in the land were given notice.
		+
		+	An exception(s) should be taken for lienholders and others who were not given proper notice of the sale. Also, remember that since this is an administrative proceeding, lis pendens does not apply.
		+
		+	7. When was the sale? The actual sale must take place not less than 10 days and no more than 40 days from the time of giving public notice of the sale (publication/posting). The sale must take place in the county where the property is located unless the IRS specifically ordered otherwise prior to the sale.
		+
		+	8. What was the sales price? The actual sales price must meet or exceed the minimum bid determined by the IRS prior to the sale. This information will be found on the Record 21.
		+
		+	9. How was the sale conducted? The sale must be conducted either by public auction or by public sale under sealed bids.
		+
		+	10. Did the taxpayer redeem? The taxpayer has 180 days to redeem the property. If less than 180 days have passed since the sale, an exception must be made for this right of redemption.
		+
		+	11. What’s in the deed from the IRS? The deed from the IRS is supposed to be issued after the expiration of the redemption period. It must specify a description of the property, the name of the taxpayer whose real estate was sold, the name of the purchaser and the price paid.
		+
		+	Where’s the taxpayer now? The taxpayer must not occupy the property or exercise dominion and control over the property after the IRS issues the deed. If the taxpayer continues to occupy the property or the buyer at the distraint sale is a relative or someone who is “just trying to help” the taxpayer out, there are significant creditor’s rights issues which may affect the property. These include, but are not limited to the reattachment of all liens against the property.
		+
		+	The Internal Revenue Manual is available online at [https://www.irs.gov/irm www.irs.gov/irm]

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:50, 15 May 2025
Line 133:		Line 133:

	The caution here is that the membership interest is owned by the member who is subject to the lien, so the lien attaches to the membership interest and to any distributions from the LLC. The extent to which the IRS can “execute” on the membership interest is also a question of state law. Some states limit the remedy to a charging lien, so that there is nothing to grab unless and until a distribution is declared.		The caution here is that the membership interest is owned by the member who is subject to the lien, so the lien attaches to the membership interest and to any distributions from the LLC. The extent to which the IRS can “execute” on the membership interest is also a question of state law. Some states limit the remedy to a charging lien, so that there is nothing to grab unless and until a distribution is declared.
		+
		+	==Foreclosure of Federal Tax Liens==

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:58, 18 November 2022
Line 125:		Line 125:

	Similarly, in the case of a life estate, the federal tax lien clearly attaches to the life tenant’s interest and may be enforced against that interest so long as the life tenant lives. However, upon the death of the life tenant, the lien ceases to attach to the property since the Government’s tax lien rights do not exceed the taxpayer’s right to the property. [https://www.irs.gov/irm/part5/irm_05-017-002.html Part 5. Collecting Process, Chapter 17. Legal Reference Guide for Revenue Officers, Section 2. Federal Tax Liens]		Similarly, in the case of a life estate, the federal tax lien clearly attaches to the life tenant’s interest and may be enforced against that interest so long as the life tenant lives. However, upon the death of the life tenant, the lien ceases to attach to the property since the Government’s tax lien rights do not exceed the taxpayer’s right to the property. [https://www.irs.gov/irm/part5/irm_05-017-002.html Part 5. Collecting Process, Chapter 17. Legal Reference Guide for Revenue Officers, Section 2. Federal Tax Liens]
		+
		+	==Tax Liens and Single Member LLCs==
		+
		+	A single member LLC is treated as a disregarded entity for federal and state tax purposes, which raises the question of whether a tax lien against the single member attaches to the assets of the LLC. The answer turns on whether state law treats the LLC as a separate legal entity, distinct from its member. That is the treatment in most states we have examined.
		+
		+	The IRS has issued [https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-wd/1116019.pdf this informal guidance] in the past confirming the non-attachment.
		+
		+	The caution here is that the membership interest is owned by the member who is subject to the lien, so the lien attaches to the membership interest and to any distributions from the LLC. The extent to which the IRS can “execute” on the membership interest is also a question of state law. Some states limit the remedy to a charging lien, so that there is nothing to grab unless and until a distribution is declared.

@@ Line 108: / Line 108: @@
 See Q4, Internal Revenue Bulletin:  [https://www.irs.gov/irb/2003-39_IRB/ar13.html 2003-39]
 Presumably, the same analysis as was applied to JTROS property should be made as to any state law exceptions to the continuation of the lien, and, of course, confirming the recognition of Tenancy by Entireties in the state.
 ===Other Terminable Interests===

@@ Line 35: / Line 35: @@
 A Purchase Money Mortgage or security interest,  '''valid under local law''' is protected, even though it may
-arise after a notice of Federal tax lien has been filed against the purchaser.  Revenue Ruling 68-57; [https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p785.pdf IRS Publication 785]  [https://casetext.com/case/united-states-v-heptner U.S. v. Heptner]
+arise after a notice of Federal tax lien has been filed against the purchaser.  Revenue Ruling 68-57; [https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p785.pdf IRS Publication 785]  [https://casetext.com/case/united-states-v-heptner U.S. v. Heptner], (MD FL 2016)
 However, a FTL against the seller has already attached and will be superior to the new mortgage.

@@ Line 46: / Line 46: @@
 While it is impossible in an article of this type to cover the foreclosure processes of 50 states, there are two common elements regarding tax liens that may affect title.
-First, notice must be given to the U.S. Government.   In a judicial foreclosure that is accomplished by serving the U.S. Attorney for the district with copies by Registered or Certified mail to the Attorney General in Washington. [http://wiki.wfgstaging.com/images/c/c6/28_USC_2410_Foreclosure_of_US_lien.pdf  28 U.S.C. §2410](b). In a non-judicial foreclosure, even in states where local practices may not require notice to subordinate lienholders, a notice of sale must be given, in writing, by registered or certified mail or by personal service, not less than 25 days prior to the sale, to the Advisory group manager, in the Field Collection Area where the sale is to be held. [http://wiki.wfgstaging.com/images/1/14/Internal_Revenue_Manual_5.12.pdf Internal Revenue Manual, § 5.12].4.4 (06-11-2010)   [http://wiki.wfgstaging.com/images/7/75/26_USC_7425_Tax_Lien_foreclosure.pdf 26 U.S.C. §7425](c)(1)).  A foreclosure sale made without proper notice may still be subject to the tax lien.
+First, notice must be given to the U.S. Government.   In a judicial foreclosure that is accomplished by serving the U.S. Attorney for the district with copies by Registered or Certified mail to the Attorney General in Washington. [http://uww.wfgnationaltitle.com/images/c/c6/28_USC_2410_Foreclosure_of_US_lien.pdf  28 U.S.C. §2410](b). In a non-judicial foreclosure, even in states where local practices may not require notice to subordinate lienholders, a notice of sale must be given, in writing, by registered or certified mail or by personal service, not less than 25 days prior to the sale, to the Advisory group manager, in the Field Collection Area where the sale is to be held. [http://uww.wfgnationaltitle.com/images/1/14/Internal_Revenue_Manual_5.12.pdf Internal Revenue Manual, § 5.12].4.4 (06-11-2010)   [http://uww.wfgnationaltitle.com/images/7/75/26_USC_7425_Tax_Lien_foreclosure.pdf 26 U.S.C. §7425](c)(1)).  A foreclosure sale made without proper notice may still be subject to the tax lien.
-Second, when an IRS lien is eliminated in foreclosure, the IRS has not less than 120 days from the date of sale within which to redeem.  Judicial [http://wiki.wfgstaging.com/images/c/c6/28_USC_2410_Foreclosure_of_US_lien.pdf 28 U.S.C. §2410](c), Non-judicial [http://wiki.wfgstaging.com/images/7/75/26_USC_7425_Tax_Lien_foreclosure.pdf 26 U.S.C. §7425](d)(1).
+Second, when an IRS lien is eliminated in foreclosure, the IRS has not less than 120 days from the date of sale within which to redeem.  Judicial [http://uww.wfgnationaltitle.com/images/c/c6/28_USC_2410_Foreclosure_of_US_lien.pdf 28 U.S.C. §2410](c), Non-judicial [http://uww.wfgnationaltitle.com/images/7/75/26_USC_7425_Tax_Lien_foreclosure.pdf 26 U.S.C. §7425](d)(1).
 Steve Winkler  11-12-14